CONTRARIAN AUDIT REPORT — EQUATIONS_SPEC.txt v1
Date: 2026-03-20
Result: 2 CRITICAL, 8 HIGH, 8 MEDIUM, 2 LOW — SPEC REQUIRES v2

CRITICAL:
  #1  Missing potential term V(psi,A) = omega_0^2 psi(1+A/A_ref) — equation doesn't match source
  #11 Boundary conditions never specified

HIGH:
  #2  Amplitude coupling half-implemented without potential term
  #5  "Both normalized to unit sphere" false — V at sqrt(2), D at 1.0
  #7  C_potential uses energy density, theory says curvature (2nd derivative)
  #9  "No additional terms" checklist masks MISSING terms
  #12 Grid resolution, domain size unspecified
  #13 CN(x) undefined for continuum field
  #17 "Does not include" omits spillover and misframes phi

MEDIUM:
  #3  nabla^4 notation means biharmonic, not 4D Laplacian
  #8  CFL lacks safety factor and grid assumptions
  #10 Energy conservation impossible with active sources
  #14 r=0.5 ceiling citation wrong (should be math_framework, not theory.txt 24-28)
  #15 Rectangular window creates FDTD Gibbs artifacts
  #18 Audit checklist missing 9 items
  #19 Three conflicting source placement options, no primary
  #20 No units system defined

LOW:
  #6  Self-dual rotation involves scaling, not just rotation
  #16 c_4D = 1+sin(45) has no derivation — label as heuristic

ADDITIONAL (from gotcha review + user directive):
  - 5D overflow dimension needed when r->0.5 in 4D
  - c_eff must be uniform across grid (prior engine gotcha)
  - CFL in 4D with c=1.8 will produce tiny dt — runtime concern